The extension is the part of your address people are most likely to get wrong. Most will assume .com unless they've seen your address written down, so the further you move from .com, the more you depend on people reading rather than hearing your domain. That's fine for a developer tool shared in documentation, and riskier for a local service recommended by word of mouth.
Cost matters too. Some extensions have higher yearly fees, and a few new ones renew at much higher prices than their first year. Compare the total cost over the years you'll use the domain, not just the first payment.